This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

In partnership with

Wednesday 18 November 2026

In your briefing today:

  • Alan Milburn unveiled proposals for sweeping reform to welfare, taxation and education, in an effort to get under-25s off benefits and into work

  • In a world rocked by IT outages, how concerned should we be?

  • Everyone says Scotland will struggle not to qualify for the European Championships we’re helping host. That sort of talk is worrying fans.

TODAY’S WEATHER

🌧️ Expect rain in Glasgow, Edinburgh and Dundee, heavy at times, while Aberdeen and Inverness will just be cloudy. It’ll be a little milder than yesterday. London will be cloudy and cool. (Here’s the UK forecast).

THE BIG STORIES
Milburn unveils proposals for sweeping reform | Final midterm blow to Trump from… Alaska, of all places | UK inflation up

📣 Alan Milburn finally unveiled his proposals for sweeping reform to avoid “losing a generation” of young people to a life on benefits. His ideas include a multi-billion-pound programme of support for “Neets” - those under-25s not in employment, education or training, tax breaks for firms who take on young people and major reforms to education.

Trade unions and some Labour MPs have voiced concerns about some of his plans, fearing that cuts to health-related benefits will drive some people into poverty.

But there are few signs that the Labour government - which has backed Milburn’s plans - will face anything like the problems Keir Starmer faced when, only a year ago, he proposed a £5 billion reduction in welfare spending. (BBC)

  • From a Welfare State to a Working State - read Milburn’s full report (Gov.uk)

  • The Prime Minister has promised to “move quickly” on the report (BBC)

  • Chris Mason: Milburn may have gifted Labour MPs a moral argument for welfare reform (BBC)

  • Patrick Butler: Milburn’s absurdly ambitious report offers blueprint for fixing everything and everyone (Guardian)

  • Janet Daley: The welfare epidemic won’t be fixed by new ways of interfering in business. Just get out of the way and give youthful energy a chance (Telegraph)

  • Scotland: John Swinney says the Scottish Government will “carefully consider” the report and warned of its “significant financial implications” (Holyrood)

📣 It’s the last, late, midterm blow to President Trump and his Republican Party: Democrat Mary Peltola has beaten the two-term Republican Senator Dan Sullivan in Alaska, ending a hotly disputed election in a state that has long been staunchly both Republican, and pro-Trump.

It’s the final Senate contest to be declared in this year’s elections, and means the Democrats have a 56-44 majority. They have flipped nine Republican-held seats across the US. (AP)

  • In Congress, it’s not clear what size the Democratic majority will be yet: recounts are underway in three races. (New York Times)

  • Electoral victory has not brought Democratic unity: the contest to be majority leader is turning ugly (New York Times)

📣 Inflation in the UK has risen again, hitting 3.6% in October, figures released at 7am this morning have confirmed. The rise was expected, and economists expect more to come as the war in Iran drives up fuel costs. (BBC)

Free, private email, now with 60% off premium this Black Friday.

A private inbox doesn’t have to come with a price tag—or a catch. Proton Mail’s free plan gives you the privacy and security you expect, without selling your data or showing you ads.

Built by scientists and privacy advocates, Proton Mail uses end-to-end encryption to keep your conversations secure. No scanning. No targeting. No creepy promotions.

With Proton, you’re not the product — you’re in control.

Start for free, or upgrade for 60% off this Black Friday. Stay private always.

AROUND SCOTLAND

📣 NHS Grampian has confirmed 18 children were operated on at Dr Gray’s hospital in Elgin after it had been told to stop because of concerns about patient safety. (STV has the exclusive)

📣 A woman who endured 14 years of treatment for a brain tumour says she only learned of the links between her illness and the contraceptive jab she had been prescribed after reading about other cases in her newspaper. (Daily Record has the exclusive)

📣 Scotland is in the middle of a “policing crisis” with around 1,000 calls a day to the force going unanswered. Officers will lobby the Scottish Parliament today to call for a return to local policing. (Scotsman)

AROUND THE UK & WORLD

📣 School pupils in England who use AI to cheat can expect “life-altering” sanctions, including losing their entire A-level or GCSE qualification, the new exam regulator has warned. (Independent)

📣 Some Nvidia directors are insisting disgraced former CEO Jensen Huang should be brought back to the chipmaker. It’s an idea he supports. (Semafor)

📣 Was Jeffrey Epstein murdered? New autopsy photos of his neck - not included in the linked story - prove that he was strangled, a forensic investigator claims. (Mail)

📣 Pills that mimic Viagra can slow Alzheimer’s progression by increasing blood flow to the brain, a new study has found. (Guardian)

SPORT

⚽️ Scotland will be the lowest-seeded British side in next month’s European Championships draw. Some have said it’s “almost impossible” for Scotland not to qualify, given we’re a co-host. That sort of talk is making many Scotland fans uneasy, given the side’s dire form under Sébastien Pocognoli. (BBC)

⚽️ Rangers legend Ralph Brand has died, aged 89. He scored 222 goals in 347 games for the club. (Sun)

IDEAS
In a world rocked by IT outages, how concerned should we be?

❝

“We’re going to have a couple of years where every single week it’s going to feel like the sky is falling.”

A technologist describes the emerging chaos in the digital (and now real) world

🗣️ Yesterday evening, as the UK was settling down for an evening in front of the TV, news was rippling across the United States about yet another tech outage. This time it was at Apple, where Apple Pay, iCloud, and Apple Music stopped working for some customers.

On X/Twitter, Taegun Lee was one of countless people caught out. He wrote that he was at a filling station and couldn’t pay for the fuel he’d just put in his tank. “I don't carry a card,” he wrote. I haven't carried a card in maybe 4 years.

“I called my wife. She's about an hour away, 60 miles, and she's driving here with cash from the jar we keep for the babysitter. I'm 41 years old and my wife is coming to bail me out of a gas station.

“The part that's getting to me isn't the embarrassment. Yesterday it was Chase and Zelle. Today it's Apple. I keep refreshing the news and every company says the same thing, "we're aware of the issue."

“When she gets here we're going straight to the grocery store. Water, canned food, rice, batteries, a couple of power banks, enough for a month. And we're taking out cash and keeping it at home.

“I used to laugh at people who did this. I'm not laughing today.”

Lee’s broad point here is one being echoed by many: what the hell is going on, and should I be worried about the apparently increasing number of incidents?

First, some caveats. First, not all of those incidents were directly caused by cyberattacks. The Microsoft, Apple, US air traffic control and (we think) NSA incidents were all caused by updates and maintenance gone wrong.

Second, every big organisation is a regular cyber-attack target, although not every attack is serious, and this has been the case for years. (I wrote a book about Cybercrime, for children (!), 25 years ago).

Third, we may also be experiencing the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon, where a threat appears everywhere once you start looking for it.

And, worst of all, we’re dependent on all this technology: even if our homes aren’t packed with smart devices, we all rely on the internet, and can’t even pay for old-fashioned fuel without tech working for us.

So far, so paranoid. But dispatches from the digital front line, from people paid to know what’s going on, do suggest we should sit up and pay attention.

  • Nicole Perlroth was the New York Times’s lead cybersecurity, digital espionage, and sabotage reporter (what a beat!). She’s written a long X/Twitter post trying to explain what’s going on. It’s worth your time, but - tl;dr - there’s been an “explosion” in severe vulnerabilities in systems, with AI accelerating how quickly they’re being exploited. “We are entering a period of unprecedented technological instability,” she writes. “This, I’m sorry to say, is just the opening chapter”.

  • Azeem Azhar, who writes and speaks on the change being wrought on our world, would agree. In his (paid) newsletter, Exponential View, he writes we are living through “The internet’s Wuhan moment”, a reference to the emergence of Covid in 2019/20. He quotes one technologist: “We’re going to have a couple of years where every single week it’s going to feel like the sky is falling.”
    “He is right,” writes Azeem. “It will get worse before it gets better. And the internet that comes out the other side will be safer, and less open, than the one we built.” Plenty of people have disagreed with Azeem’s assessment but, for my money, I think he’s got it about right. (Exponential View (£))

  • Maybe AI can help us fight back, too. Ronee Hulk, who readers will remember from the start of the year is the Edinburgh-based author who wrote a book explaining AI, has concerns - and a modest fix. He’s just launched a new service tracking what they call “Synthetic Emergency Denials of Service” - where an AI-powered hoax diverts resources - an ambulance, say - away from real need, in a deliberate attempt to disrupt. Read more about Ronee’s attempt to counter that on LinkedIn.

You’ll note that much of today’s post is drawn from social media: I’m not seeing especially deep mainstream coverage yet of what’s going on. It’ll come, and I’ll keep you posted here. Not to cause alarm, you understand, but in our own small act of resistance. After all, forewarned is forearmed, and while technological advances are inevitable, what we allow them to do to us - and society - remains malleable.

I choose to be optimistic, but prepared.

  • Your views, as ever, are very welcome. Hit reply and let me know what you’d like more of, less of, what your worries are, what reassures you. I’m all ears as are - I suspect - thousands of like-minded Early Line readers.

👍 That’s your Early Line for the day

Sent this by a friend?